Navigating Leadership Challenges in the Local Church

There’s nothing quite like the heartbreak of a church staff team led by church leaders falling apart due to divisions and conflicts. Though Jesus did give us a heads-up that the path to unity wouldn't be a walk in the park, it’s still a tough pill to swallow when local church community begins to fall apart. Unity isn't just a “nice-to-have,” either; it’s a potent demonstration of His presence and power among us and a Biblical mandate (John 17; Ephesians 4:3).

Typically, disunity doesn’t happen overnight—it’s often a slow-moving train wreck that’s been picking up steam for a while. This article aims to be your handy guide through the maze of leadership challenges, so that your church doesn't just survive, but thrives with love, unity, and strength.

What Constitutes a "Leadership Challenge"?

In the serene sanctuary of the local church, a leadership challenge can be as quiet as a disagreement over scripture interpretation or as loud as a theological debate that splits the congregation into factions. Here’s a sampler of what these challenges could look like:

Interpersonal disputes.

The Church brings together a myriad of personalities, opinions, and backgrounds. With the beautiful diversity of the Body of Christ also comes plenty of opportunities for petty arguments, offense, and genuine hurt. When interpersonal disputes aren’t mediated or resolved, they can escalate into stand-offs and silent treatments...among staff, volunteers, and regular church members.

Communication hurdles.

Even well-intended followers of Jesus can tend to avoid conflict with Christian brothers and sisters. Unfortunately, this can turn into a lack of healthy communication about everything from logistics to theology. Alternatively, there may be a “top-down” leadership structure that doesn’t leave a lot of room for exchanging ideas or giving feedback. Either way, hurdles in communication can result in larger problems (like poorly run church services and high staff turnover).

Theological disagreements.

We’ve all heard stories about churches that split over theological differences, whether that centers on gifts of the Spirit, predestination, or some form of the prosperity gospel. While some theological differences may be legitimate grounds for re-organizing a church, some doctrinal disagreements can be settled on “agree to disagree”....even on the same church staff.

Directional decisions.

Church ministry initiatives–whether that’s launching an outreach ministry, appointing a new pastor, or launching a Saturday service–can spark endless debates. When debates aren’t mediated well, they can morph into tense disagreement.

Budgeting decisions.

Determining how best to utilize limited resources, including financial budgets, can lead to significant leadership challenges. Choices about where to allocate funds or how to prioritize different ministry needs often stir up tensions, especially when the stakes are high and resources are scarce. Leaders must navigate these decisions carefully to maintain transparency, fairness, and alignment with the church’s mission and vision.

(Of course, it also helps to start with a foundation of financial health).

Easy-to-use Church Management Software

Start using powerful, yet intuitive, church management software that's been designed to help you save time, reduce frustration, and accomplish your church's goals.

Start a Free Trial of Breeze

10 Strategies for Handling Challenges on Staff and in Your Church

Chances are, your church is facing at least one of the challenges listed above. Depending on the problem, this can feel enormously stressful, disappointing, and discouraging. Good news: There’s hope. But you’ll need more than just good intentions and great leadership skills. You may need to try a variety of strategies that can help you navigate the rough waters of church disunity.

Here are ten strategies that might just prevent your church from shipwrecking on the shore of disagreement:

1. Start with an Open Discussion – Create a space where staff members can air out issues before they escalate. This starts with modeling a church culture that makes it safe to disagree. With the Bible as your guide and source of Truth, solutions are often just around the corner.
2. Hire a Mediator or Coach – Hire mentors or seasoned mediators to guide difficult conversations. Having a third party that doesn’t go to your church can be enormously helpful when navigating conflict...just make sure the coach or mentor is committed to Bible-based principles.
3. Repent and Embrace Discipleship –Sometimes, disagreements in a church can stem from a lack of adherence to God’s word and the teachings of Christ. Repentance helps people lay their egos aside and instead pursue the way of Jesus (By the way, this applies to everyone–from the lead pastor to the volunteer admin).
4. Ask for Forgiveness and Offer Restoration – Not just a formality, forgiveness is about genuinely rebuilding broken bridges. In the letter to the church at Ephesus, Paul said, “Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace.” That includes asking for forgiveness when forgiveness is required.
5. Do Something Fun Together as a Team – Remember that following Jesus together is fun! Planning a weekend team retreat, an all-day team-building activity, or even just a fun dinner at a great restaurant can do wonders for resolving challenges.
6. Build New Policies to Prevent Further Challenges – Create clear and flexible policies that guide decision-making and anticipate future issues. These policies should cover communication, roles, responsibilities, and how to handle conflicts. Regularly update these guidelines with input from your team to keep them effective and relevant.
7. Check in and Ask for Feedback – Regularly talk to your church staff to check on their well-being and get their feedback. Use one-on-one meetings, anonymous surveys, or informal chats to understand their concerns and suggestions. This helps prevent small issues from becoming bigger and strengthens team trust and cohesion.
8. Give it Time and Pray for Guidance from the Holy Spirit – Understand that not all problems can be solved quickly. Take time to pray and seek guidance from the Holy Spirit, trusting that healing and solutions will come in time. Encourage regular prayer among the team for divine direction and patience.
9. Pursue Integrity in Leadership Development – Be a role model of honesty and transparency. Develop your leadership skills through training, mentorship, and ongoing education. Create an environment where everyone upholds strong ethical standards and reflects the values taught in the Bible.
10. Learn and Implement Conflict-Resolution Strategies – Equip yourself and your team with skills to handle disputes effectively. Focus on active listening, empathy, negotiation, and mediation. Organize training sessions on conflict resolution to help everyone manage disagreements constructively and maintain unity in the church.

Create a Healthy Foundation for Church Management with Breeze

Ever experience a poorly planned church service, disorganized meeting, or choppy flow of communication? Of course you have. Sometimes, the root of all challenges (or at least most church drama) can be traced back to logistical problems.

Enter Breeze, the church management software that’s designed to lift the burdens of administration, ensuring that communication flows freely. With Breeze, you can store contact information, receive online donations, track attendance, schedule volunteers, manage budgets, plan worship services, send out group emails, and much more. So, before you schedule another tense meeting or plan an intervention, maybe give Breeze a try—your sanity (and your secretary) will thank you.

Navigating leadership challenges in the church isn’t for the faint of heart. But with the right strategies, tools, and a commitment to ongoing leadership development, you can turn potential battlegrounds into opportunities for growth and deeper unity. After all, a church united can stand against anything—even church politics.